OnSET: The Online Science, Enginering and Technology Review

Search OnSET

OnSET's mascot!

OnSET is an online science magazine, written and produced by students. [more]

OnSET Issue 6 launches for UNSW Info Day 2006!

Worldwide Day in Science
University students from around the world are taking a snapshot of scientific endeavour.

View A Day in the Life of Science in Australia 2005.

Sunswift III
The UNSW Solar Racing Team is embarking on an exciting new project, to design and build the most advanced solar car ever built in Australia.

Outreach Centre for Sciences
UNSW Science students can visit your school to present an exciting Science Show or planetarium session.

South Pole Diaries
Follow the daily adventures of UNSW astronomers at the South Pole and Dome C through these diaries.

 

 

Are we Alone in the Universe? --- SETI and Drake’s Equation

Yun Hwang

Ever recalled watching ET: The Extra-Terrestrial? I certainly do. At that point of time, I walked away with two thoughts – one: the girl I was sitting next to in the movie did not really like me, and two: I really wanted a friend like ET. Although the thought of a friend with mystical powers is nice, it was the idea of living on a giant spaceship and sailing among the stars that captivated me. As I turn my eyes toward the night sky, I can not help but wonder if there is really someone out there cruising through the galaxies.

Many people have claimed to see Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) soar the skies, but who know whether its a photographic trick or whether if there is really something out there.

With the developments of science and our interest in space, the thought of not being alone is growing in our consciousness. Like any controversial issue, the existence of life beyond Earth is supported by many believers and disapproved by many unbelievers. “Are we alone in the Universe?” The answer to this fundamental question will inevitably impact human existence. The existence of an extraterrestrial culture more advanced than ours, whether benign or hostile, would confront our curiosity and pose difficult challenges. Even if the answer to the question is ‘yes, we are alone,’ that will indicate how precious life, sentience and intelligence are, and that there will be a desperate need to foster, develop, protect and preserve the unique environment of the Earth.

Currently, it is not known whether ETs are out there and the issue revolving around the existence of ETs cannot be resolved by argument alone. Thus in the 1950s’, a long-term multinational project called ‘Search for Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence’ (SETI) began. SETI started its quest by directing a radiotelescope toward the sky and listening for any signals that could have been emitted by another intelligent culture. This search was based on a number of key assumptions: that ETs are close enough for their emissions to be detected on our radiotelescopes and that their emissions would be along the same frequency as ours.

Until now, except for an unidentified signal that was heard once and only once, there have been no other detections that might be emissions by ETs. Skeptics of the program exploited the opportunity to claim this lack of evidence as proof that ETs do not exist. Others who are more optimistic have suggested that the ETs in our neighbourhood of the universe are just a very quiet bunch. Researchers have found that these optimists may not be far from the truth. Over the last 50 years, the level of radio emission escaping the Earth’s atmosphere has decreased significantly as the efficiency of telecommunications, radar, and the like increase; likewise this could be an indication that the ETs may very well have reduced their radiowave emissions.

While there is no concrete argument for the existence of ET, and postulations are based on zero evidence, scientists are at their wits’ end when it comes to formulas and equations. In 1961, Dr Frank Drake formulated an equation (that is presently named in his honour – Drake’s Equation) to limit the maximum number of technological civilizations in our galaxy. Believe it or not, even the skeptics accept the equation as a valid method of estimating the number of ET civilizations that are potentially out there.

So, what exactly is this equation that has brought all the dissenting opinions together? It is presented as:

N = R* • fp • ne • fl • fi • fc • L

Where each variable represents an estimate based on the best available scientific knowledge, as follows:

N = The number of civilizations in The Milky Way Galaxy whose electromagnetic
emissions are detectable. So if there are any ETs, we may be able to get in touch.

R* = The rate of formation of stars suitable for the development of intelligent life.

fp = The fraction of those stars with planetary systems.

ne = The number of planets, per solar system, with an environment suitable for life.

fl = The fraction of suitable planets on which life actually appears.

fi = The fraction of life bearing planets on which intelligent life emerges.

fc = The fraction of civilizations that had developed a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space.

L = The length of time such civilizations release detectable signals into space.

Although this equation has been the means of bringing people on both sides of the divide together, it has initiated hotly contested arguments on the values of each variable in the equation. For instance, some people argue that the values of fl, fi and fc are whatever it takes to make N = 1, then that will make humans the only intelligent life releasing detectable signs of our existence into space. With respect to the other values, they are difficult to estimate, considering that scientists do not yet have an appropriate model of our vast universe and its planets to carry out experiments and investigations on. As a result, the values are merely speculations, hence accounting for the wide range in estimates of each value.

To refer to this as an issue that will not be resolved easily is an understatement. The Milky Way Galaxy is vast, and Drake’s Equation only illuminates key factors that are involved. The answer to the fundamental questions will remain unanswered until the aliens come knocking on our doors, or until humans develop their technology to scan in a thorough way a fairly large fraction of the Milky Way Galaxy and beyond. The latter is unexpected in the near future, and the former is seemingly not probable at all. So for now, we will continue to ponder … to wait … to listen in silence, looking for any potentially meaningful noise that penetrates our surroundings.

Then again, who knows? ET might arrive on our doorstep tomorrow and give us the answer.

Further Reading:

www.seti.org
http://www.setileague.org/
http://www.activemind.com/Mysterious/Topics/SETI/drake_equation.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation
http://www.homoexcelsior.com/omega.db/datum/extraterrestrial_life/ drake's_equation/8525
http://www.jb.man.ac.uk/research/seti/drake.html
http://www.the-ba.net/the-ba/ResourcesforLearning/BACRESTAwards/ProjectIdeas/Space/ IsAnybodyOutThere/Drakesequation.htm

OnSET is an initiative of the Science Communication Program
URL: http://www.onset.unsw.edu.au     Enquiries: onset@unsw.edu.au
Authorised by: Will Rifkin, Science Communication
Site updated: 3 January 2006     © UNSW 2003 | Disclaimer
Science UNSW - The Best Choice
CRICOS Provider Code: 00098G